by Alessandro de Maigret
Stacey International, London 2002. Pp 384. Maps, Plans,
Tables, Charts, B &W illus, Index. Hb. £22. 50. ISBN
1-900988-070.
Travellers in the Yemen who have managed to reach Baraqish will
know of Professor de Maigret as the archaeologist who, starting in
1992, excavated the Minaean temple just inside the entrance gate of
that splendid ruined city. The more initiated will also know of him
as the Director of the Italian Archaeological Mission which, from
1983 onwards, made a series of important discoveries concerning the
Yemen’s prehistory and protohistory and the origins of the Early
South Arabian culture — the civilisation of the Sabaeans,
Minaeans, Qatabanians, and the rest. Any work by a scholar with such
a record of achievement demands our attention.
This book, an English translation by Rebecca Thompson of the
Italian edition first published in 1996, describes these
investigations clearly and precisely. Skilfully choosing the right
places from which to start their search, the Mission found traces of
the palaeolithic period both on the Yemen plateau south-west of
Marib and in western stretches of the Ramlat Sabatayn, together with
neolithic sites on the plateau and on the Red Sea Tihama. In the
basin of the Wadi Dhana, which feeds the plains of Marib, the team
then located a pre-Sabaean Bronze Age site from the 2nd/3rd
millennium BC, a period previously unknown to Yemen archaeology. By
1985 it was focussing its attention on Yala, a very early Sabaean
settlement southwest of Marib which had been abandoned in the
6th/7th century BC and had never been re-occupied. Carefully
calibrated radio carbon tests from here have produced dates from the
lowest levels of between 1395 and 795 BC, a finding which not only
conformed with the American dating at Hajar bin Humayd, in Bayhan
but also firmly disposed of any remaining arguments for Dr Pirenne’s
‘short’ chronology for the origin of South Arabian writing,
which she believed derived from classical Greece. A Sabaean
boustrophedon inscription found at Yala (illustrated on page 182)
and attributed to the 7th century BC is written in a remarkably
elegant and mature style for its date. De Maigret sees the Early
South Arabian culture as stretching back to the 14th century BC or
even earlier, but with a gap between then and the recognisably very
different culture of the Bronze Age which preceded it; the inference
is that the South Arabians may perhaps have originally been nomads
from the north who intruded on the Bronze Age inhabitants.
The importance of the findings of de Maigret and his team to
those studying the Yemen’s early history goes without saying, but
the book encompasses a much wider field, as its sub-title reveals.
Most of the first hundred pages summarise the story of the
archaeological and epigraphical explorations in the country up to
the American expedition under Wendell Phillips (who visited Bayhan
on his first reconnaissance in 1949, not 1947 as stated). These are
described in some detail and sources are quoted meticulously, making
this part a valuable point of reference. A major section on ‘The
Kingdoms of Arabia Felix’ then discusses the early historical
period and contains useful elucidations of issues which had for long
proved perplexing — the difference between kings and mukarribs,
the arguments about ‘long’, ‘middle’ and ‘short’
chronologies, and the significance of ‘dhu-Raydan’ in the royal
titles, for example. Chapters on ‘Religion’, ‘The City’, ‘The
Temples’ (which includes a description of de Maigret’s
excavations in Baraqish) and ‘The Tombs’ lead to an interesting
review of the figurative arts, although here he is a purist with
little time for the local art of the later period, which reflected
the fashions of ancient Greece and Rome and which he regards in
consequence as decadent. Each chapter is fully supported with
footnotes detailing sources, but the book has no bibliography.
It will be apparent that Arabia Felix is not a
comprehensive guide to the Yemen’s archaeological sites such as,
in respect of South Yemen, was Brian Doe’s Southern Arabia when
published in 1971. Both books were written in the days before Yemeni
unification, and just as Doe could not enter North Yemen (although
his Monuments of South Arabia (1983) did reproduce some
published information about some of the major North Yemeni sites)
neither could de Maigret in his time enter the South. ‘Crossing
[the northern reaches of] Wadi Harib’, de Maigret writes, ‘I
couldn’t help thinking that only a few kilometres to the south in
the inaccessible (for us) PDR Y lay the heart of Qataban, the
glorious capital of Timna’. I could empathise with that sense of
frustration utterly, having on many occasions in much earlier years,
with free access to Timna, stood in the southern parts of
Wadi Harib and thought how tantalisingly close but equally
inaccessible lay the heart of Saba, the glorious but still
mysterious capital of Marib!
Accordingly, de Maigret sticks to the places he knows personally,
which are all in the former North Yemen. He acknowledges the
contemporaneous work of other archaeologists but, although drawing
on their discoveries to reach his conclusions, he does not describe
it in any detail. Unfortunately this approach leads to a sense of
imbalance in the book as a whole; for instance, in the first
section, two pages on what Philby saw at Shabwa during his short
visit there in 1936 whet the appetite, but there is almost nothing
at all in the later pages about what the French discovered there
during several seasons of excavation starting in 1976. Nor for that
matter are there more than brief references, if any, to the American
excavations in Wadi Jubah, Russian work in Hadramawt and Qana,
German investigations in Marib, or the various British, German and
Canadian operations in the western and southern Tihamas. Markha, the
homeland of the ancient kingdom of Awsan, is mentioned only
obliquely, although the French had examined its considerable
archaeological traces long before de Maigret reached the Yemen. Some
of these omissions arise from the fact that Arabia Felix was
first published in 1996. A very short Publisher’s Note has been
added to cover the missing period, but some of de Maigret’s
comments on the chronology demonstrate that they were written before
much of Robin’s work was concluded and before Kitchen’s
king-lists had seen the light of day. His book nevertheless provides
an authoritative and scholarly overview of the South Arabian
civilisation as a whole.
The book has been nicely produced and is lavishly illustrated
with maps, drawings, plans, tables and photographs, although the
referencing of the photographs by plate numbers without stating on
what pages they appear is irritating, as one often has to trawl
extensively to find a picture mentioned in the text. There are a few
editorial failures too, most noticeably the loss of the plan of
Qarnaw, which should be on page 77 but has somehow been replaced
there by a stratigraphic drawing of Yala already reproduced two
pages earlier. But this is still a very readable and informative
book, which fills a long-standing gap for both students and
travellers, and everyone with any interest in South Arabia’s
ancient past will certainly want a copy of it on his or her
bookshelves.
Oh yes! What about the Queen of Sheba? Professor de Maigret
offers an ingenious new solution, but I will not queer his pitch by
relating it here.
NIGEL GROOM