|
|
Unofficial
Communiqué - back issues, 1998 (b) |
|
|
|
|
|
OPPOSITION
TO BORDER TALKS AUGUST 8:
The joint Yemeni-Saudi military committee met again in Riyadh on August 4, amid continuing
efforts to cool the border dispute between the two neighbours.
The Saudi foreign minister, Prince Saud al-Faisal, met
President Salih in Yemen on July 28 to discuss the border dispute. This followed a visit
to Saudi Arabia by the Yemeni foreign minister, Abd al-Qadir Bagammal on July 25.
However, these moves have not been particularly well
received in Yemen. A conference of politicians, journalists, lawyers and
academics organised by the Yemen Times called on the Yemeni government to suspend all
border talks "until it achieves equitable bargaining conditions."
The independent weekly, al-Ra'y al-'Aam, went even
further. In a leading article headed "War - the only solution", it said:
"There seems to be no other solution for the yemeni-Saudi border dispute but to go to
war. Yemen has honestly and continuously made brotherly gestures and many compromises to
Saudi Arabia. But the greed of our "big sister" knows no bounds
Declare
general mobilisation and open military training camps for volunteers. Arm four million
fighters and send them to purge the Yemeni land."
The latest flare-up in the 60-year-old dispute came on
July 20 when, according to Yemen, nine Saudi naval vessels used long-range artillery to
attack and occupy al-Duwaima island, killing three Yemenis and wounding nine. Later, Yemen
said it had re-captured al-Duwaima, the Red Sea island occupied by the Saudis two days
earlier. Officials in Sana'a said Yemeni naval forces landed at dawn on July 22, but later
Saudi Arabia denied the claim.
The Saudi attack was perceived by Yemen as highly
provocative, and a breach Article 8 of the 1995 Memorandum
of Understanding between the two neighbours - though later the Saudi Interior
Minister, Prince Nayef bin Abd al-Aziz, claimed his country had acted "in
self-defence".
Military incidents between the two neighbours are common.
The Yemeni interior minister was quoted as saying: "During one month between June 15
to July 15 Saudi forces perpetrated 73 violations, most of them establishing a presence
and opening fire on Yemeni citizens and violating the airspace and sea on our borders
Our Saudi brothers are eating up the land in a big way."
In an earlier
incident on May 24-25, Saudi forces moved into a Red Sea archipelago which is
also claimed by Yemen. At least seven islands, just over 100 km west of Midi, were
involved. According to the Yemeni opposition newspaper, al-Jamahir, the Saudis landed on a
small island which was undefended by Yemeni troops and cleared off the eight fishermen
they found there. Within 12 hours they began erecting pre-fabricated buildings and
installing military positions. The newspaper said they had also occupied a second island
in the group and were seeking to evacuate inhabitants from the remainder as a precondition
for talks with Yemeni officials.
Geographical names in the area often have several
variations. Al-Jamahir (May 28) named the occupied island as "Dhu-Hurab", while
the Palestinian newspaper, al-Quds al-Arabi (May 26), referred to it as
"Huraym".
Only a small part of the frontier between has Yemen and
Saudi Arabia ever been defined [click here for
background]. The agreed portion of the land border ends at the Red Sea about
5km north of Midi. Yemen maintains that a north-westerly bend in the line just before it
reaches the sea indicates that the maritime border should continue in the same direction.
The Saudis, on the other hand, prefer to draw the line in a westerly direction, giving
them more of the Red Sea.
The islands occupied last May are south of Yemen's
preferred line - suggesting that the Saudis are staking a claim to their own projection of
the maritime border.
One possible factor in the renewed tension is the choice
of Abd al-Karim al-Iryani as Yemeni
prime minister - since he is disliked by the Saudis. The customary congratulations on his
appointment last May were not forthcoming from Riyadh.
Since late June, there have been numerous clashes between Yemen's security forces
and armed tribes in al-Jawf and Ma'rib - two northern Yemeni provinces bordering Saudi
Arabia. The tribes have blown several holes in a pipeline which supplies almost 40% of
Yemen's oil. There are strong suspicions among Yemeni politicians that the tribes' action
was encouraged, and perhaps funded, by the Saudis.
Saudi Arabia has also informed the United Nations that it
does not accept the border agreement signed by Yemen and its eastern neighbour, Oman, six
years ago. In a memorandum to the UN General Secretariat last April, the kingdom suggested
that it might have a claim to some of the territory covered by the Yemeni-Omani agreement.
The move surprised some diplomats because Riyadh did not
formally oppose the border settlement in 1992. It may be linked to the Saudis' desire for
an oil corridor to the Arabian Sea, between Yemen and Oman.
Oman's foreign minister, Youssef bin Alawi bin Abdullah,
left Saudi Arabia on July 20 after a surprise meeting with Saudi's Crown Prince Abdullah.
Oman had earlier protested about the Saudi attitude, arguing that the 1992 deal with Yemen
and a 1990 agreement with Saudi Arabia had finalised international boundary issues.
In May, Prince Sultan bin Abd al-Aziz, the Saudi Defence
Minister, paid an inspection visit to the border province of Najran, which Yemen ceded to
the kingdom under the Treaty of Ta'if in 1934. Many Yemenis regarded the prince's visit as
provocative.
According to the Ba'athist newspaper, al-Jamahir (July
17), Saudi authorities recently detained a number of Yemenis for 10 days after they
entered the Abha area, which is off-limits to Yemenis. The group were arrested on their
way back after delivering goods and were fined 4,000 Saudi riyals each.
|
|
DEATH PENALTY FOR
KIDNAPPING AUGUST 8: President
Salih has issued a decree imposing the death penalty for "anyone who leads a band of
kidnappers or bandits or who loots public or private property". The statement in
al-Thawra (the government daily) added: "Accomplices will receive the same
punishment."
The decree, issued on August 2, takes effect immediately
but will need parliamentary approval after the summer recess. A few days earlier the
cabinet approved a draft law which would make kidnapping and hijacking capital offences.
The terms of the decree are relativley broad, potentially allowing it to be applied to a
wide range of crimes.
On its own, the decree is unlikely to make much difference
to kidnapping; the problem up to now has been an inability or reluctance to arrest
kidnappers rather than a lack of suitable punishments.
But it does show that the government is beginning to
grapple with the kidnapping issue, which, according to the Yemen Times (July 13) has
caused a 22% drop in tourism and cost Yemen $28 million in the first half of this year.
The announcement of new penalties was almost certainly
timed to coincide with a three-day gathering in Sanaa of tribes from Marib, al-Jawf
and Shabwa - provinces where the government often has difficulty in maintaining control.
After the conference, President Salih praised the tribal
leaders for their decision to condemn the kidnapping of foreigners. But the full list of
conference resolutions shows that the tribes expect a lot from the president in return:
- Giving these regions' high school graduates priority in
getting scholarships;
- Giving citizens of these governorates priority in
employment by petroleum companies operating there;
- Allocating a specific number of seats at the Military
College for young men from this region;
- Giving the opportunity to unemployed young men to enlist in
the army;
- Giving more opportunity to people from these regions to
occupy government posts there;
- Providing prominent figures in the regions a recognized
official status;
- Resolving the problems of army officers and soldiers
suspended from work;
- Condemning the kidnapping of foreigners;
- Rejecting accusations of being foreign agents; and
- Forming a special committee headed by Sheikh Saleh Bin
Sowda to follow up implementation of development projects in the region.
|
|
HEAVY RAINS BRING
DESTRUCTION AUGUST 25:
The death toll in the recent heavy rains and flash floods has now reached more than 70,
according to al-Shoura newspaper (23.8.98). Heaviest casualties were in Hodeidah province
(25 dead) and Ibb (20 dead).
Hundreds of houses were swept away, including more than
300 in Sana'a - 120 of them in the city itself. In the countryside, large numbers of
livestock were drowned and roads in many parts of the country are in a worse state than
usual.
The rain has also unearthed land mines which were buried
in the south during the 1994 war, and in the Ma'rib area during the 1970s and 1980s. In
Dhali', two men died when a bomb which had been uncovered by rain exploded (al-Ayyam
23.8.98).
But the rain brought good news for the Ma'rib dam,
which now contains more than 117 million cubic metres of water (al-Ayyam 23.8.98).
|
|
ALL THE PRESIDENT'S
MEN? WITH Yemen's first direct presidential
elections due in little more than a year, the haggling in qat-filled rooms is already
under way. The first pre-election talks between President Salih's General People's
Congress and the Yemen Socialist Party (supposedly private but widely reported in the
press) broke off after several days.
President Salih, who has been in power in Sana'a since
1978, says talk of his candidacy is premature. He may even feign reluctance and have to be
"persuaded" by his friends. But who will stand against him?
From unification in 1990 until shortly after the war of
1994, Yemen had a five-member presidential council, elected by parliament. Technically,
Ali Abdullah Salih was merely its chairman - though in practice he was much more than
that.
On September 29, 1994, parliament approved a series of
amendments to the constitution which, among other things, abolished the presidential
council and replaced it with a one-man presidency. Two days later, under the new rules,
parliament elected Salih as president for a five-year term. He won easily, with 253 votes
out of the 259 members present. Representatives of a further 42 constituencies were
absent.
Other candidates were:
- Sheikh Abdul Majid Zindani (Islah)
- Ali Saleh Abbad Muqbil (YSP)
- Faisal Bin Shamlan, oil minister (independent)
- Abd al-Wahhab Mahmoud (Socialist Arab Baath)
Under the constitution, subsequent presidential elections
will be conducted by a direct vote of the people.
The process has never been tried in Yemen before, and the constitution is not entirely clear about how
it should work.
To guarantee a competitive election, the constitution
insists that there must be at least two candidates. But that may cause some difficulty
because the constitution also says all candidates must be approved by at least 10% of the
members of parliament - i.e. 31 members (Article 107). Only two parties - the GPC and
Islah - have a sufficient number of seats to do this on their own. The independents might
be able to field a candidate if they could agree among themselves on a nomination. The
YSP, which boycotted the 1997 parliamentary elections, has no members and cannot field a
candidate unless another party does so on its behalf - hence the recent discussions with
the GPC.
A problem could arise if Islah decided to boycott the
election: the GPC would then be forced to nominate two candidates to compete against each
other - which would allow opposition parties to denounce the election as a sham.
However, there is a way to minimise the possibility of a
boycott and also ensure a good turn-out: by holding unified Yemen's first local government
elections at the same time. That, in effect, would mean that any party boycotting the
presidential election would also forfeit its chance for a role in local government.
There is further a question over the likely date of the
election. The president's current term lasts for five calendar years from the date the
constitutional oath, in this case October 2, 1994 (Article 111). The election must be
completed at least one week before the expiry date (Article 113). This suggests an
election on Saturday September 25, 1999, but there are a couple of complications. Firstly,
it is unclear whether "completion" of the election means just the balloting or
the whole process, including the count. In the 1997 parliamentary election, counting took
almost a week, so possibly the voting should take place on September 18. Secondly, if no
candidate wins an overall majority, the electoral process has to be repeated, between the
two candidates with the highest number of votes (Article 107). Ideally, therefore, the
election should be held early enough to allow for two separate ballots to be held, and
counted, with a week to spare before October 2.
On the other hand, there are circumstances in which the
election may be postponed beyond its due date. Parliament (in which the president's party
has an overwhelming majority) may delay it for up to 90 days if the election "cannot
take place for any reason". Parliament may also approve a delay beyond 90 days
"if the country is in a state of war, or suffering a natural disaster or another
emergency situation, under which electing the President becomes impossible" (Article
113).
If the current state of insecurity in many parts of the
country continues, it would not be difficult to justify postponing the election. However,
the record of democratisation since 1990, and the ever-present need for legitimacy
suggests President Salih will try to avoid that. He would dearly love to become the first
president of Yemen elected directly, competitively, by the people. His victory is almost a
foregone conclusion if the election takes place, but it will be a hollow victory unless
opposition parties put up a decent fight.
What the president's opponents must decide over the next
few months is this: whether, by standing (and inevitably losing) against him, they will
simply enhance the president's reputation at their own expense, or whether a truly
competitive election - regardless of the outcome - will better serve the long-term
interests of democracy in Yemen.
|
|
YEMEN WINS HUNAISH
RULING YEMENI television interrupted
its normal programmes on October 9 to announce that Yemen has won its dispute with Eritrea
over the Hunaish archipelago in the Red Sea.
Eritrean forces seized Greater Hunaish island in December
1995 and, after much diplomatic wrangling, both sides agreed to submit their territorial
claims to an international court. A panel of five judges has been holding deliberations in
London.
The Yemeni Prime Minister, Dr Abd al-Karim al-Iryani, said
"the panel unanimously ruled that the Republic of Yemen had sovereignty over the
disputed islands."
A cursory glance at the text
of the tribunal's ruling might suggest that the outcome is a compromise.
Three paragraphs award territory to Eritrea, two award territory to Yemen, and the sixth
paragraph deals with fishing rights. The document is plainly constructed in order to
appear even-handed, making the ruling acceptable to both sides.
But what the tribunal has actually done is review
sovereignty over all the Red Sea islands that might conceivably be the subject of a
dispute between the two countries. It covers the whole area from Jabal al-Tayr (which lies
north of Sana'a) to southern rocks roughly on the same lattitude as Ta'izz. Many of these
were not, in fact, at issue during the 1995 conflict.
The Zuqar-Hunaish group of islands, which was occupied by
Eritrea in 1995 has been returned by the tribunal to Yemen. Eritrea has sovereignty over
smaller islands and rocks to the south-west.
The tribunal has not apportioned fishing rights. It says
that regardless of sovereignty, the "traditional fishing regime" in the area
should remain, with "free access and enjoyment for the fishermen of both Eritrea and
Yemen."
The judges' decision is legally binding, and both sides
have 90 days to comply.
See: Eritrea and
the dispute over Hunaish
|
|
NEW MOVES IN BORDER DISPUTE SAUDI ARABIA appears to have switched to a more conciliatory
approach in its long-running border dispute with Yemen. For a long time, the kingdom has
firmly rejected Yemeni suggestions that the issue might be settled by international
arbitration. But two recent statements have accepted this as a possibility.
On November 4, Prince Nayef bin Abd al-Aziz, the Saudi
Interior Minister, was quoted as saying: "We don't mind resolving all our problems
through negotiations or referring suspended issues to the International Court of
Justice."
In an interview with the Arab Times newspaper in Kuwait,
he also denied that Saudi Arabia is seeking a corridor
to the Arabian Sea - a demand that has often been rumoured to be a sticking point in the
negotiations. "Saudi Arabia did not think one day about getting a sea port here or
there. We had neither talked about this matter nor declared it through the press,"
the prince said.
Two days later, in an interview with the Saudi Gazette and
Okaz, Crown Prince Abdullah also said that arbitration was not ruled out: "We in the
kingdom are not against arbitration, if the brothers in Yemen desire that."
According to Yemeni sources, the Saudis have resisted
proposals for arbitration because they want changes to the line defined by the Ta'if
Treaty - allegedly for security reasons. However, this is only part of the frontier that
has ever been agreed and it would be difficult to persuade an arbitration panel to make
changes.
Pressure to refer the dispute to arbitration appears to
have grown after the International Court's ruling on the Hunaish
Islands brought a peaceful - and apparently amicable - end to the border
quarrel between Yemen and Eritrea.
The Saudi princes' remarks came shortly after Yemen's
Parliamentary Speaker, Sheikh Abdullah bin Hussein al-Ahmar, predicted that the
Yemeni-Saudi dispute "could continue with our grandchildren for tens of years".
The sheikh, who is also leader of the main opposition party, Islah, was quoted by
al-Ittihad newspaper in Abu Dhabi as saying that arbitration would be "the final
resort when we despair from bilateral negotiations". He added: "We are not at
this stage yet."
Full background to the border
dispute
|
|
ALI NASSER
VISITS ADEN THE FORMER president of South
Yemen, Ali Nasser Mohammed, recently paid a four-day visit to Aden early in November,
giving rise to speculation about its purpose.
Ex-president Mohammed, who was deposed in 1986 during a
bloody coup involving rival factions of the Yemen Socialist Party (YSP), lives in exile in
Syria but enjoys reasonably good relations with President Salih.
It is thought that his visit was connected with the fourth
general conference of the YSP, scheduled for 28-30 November. According to the independent
newspaper, Attariq
(17.11.98), he was seeking a reconciliation between the Yemeni leadership and members of
the Socialist Party living abroad who wished to attend the conference.
The Yemeni Unitary Congregation's newspaper, Attagamu'
(16.11.98) said he was seeking confirmation from President Salih that the general amnesty
for socialists (excluding the leaders convicted after the 1994 secession attempt) was
still valid. President Salih is believed to have been in Aden at the time of his visit
and, according to Attagamu' confirmed the amnesty. On the other hand, Al-Umma (19.11.98),
the weekly newspaper of the Haqq party, quoted sources close to ex-President Mohammed as
saying that his mediation attempt had failed.
There was further speculation in Attariq (17.11.98) that
Mohammed had brought Salih a request from the president of the United Arab Emirates for
information about Yemen's tactics during the recent international arbitration over the
Hunaish archipelago. The paper suggested that such information might benefit the UAE in
its dispute with Iran over islands in the Gulf.
Meanwhile Al-Thawri, the Socialist Party
newspaper (12.11.98) reported that the Central Committee had met on November 5-7 and
completed preparations for the party conference. It said guests invited to attend would
include ex-President Mohammed and members of the Russian Communist Party. It added that
three Yemen Socialist Party members would be coming from the United States.
|
|
"YEMEN
TIMES" CASE DROPPED THE GOVERNMENT
has dropped its prosecution of the Yemen Times over an article which
claimed that the country had received $22.5 billion in hard currency over the last 20
years and asked: "Where did it go?" The government prosecutors had claimed that
figures given in the article, on November 9, were wrong.
A statement issued by the newspaper on December 4 said:
"While we were sure that we would win the case, we did not know that it would last
for such a short period.
"Standing up for its rights, Yemen Times challenged
that its sources indicate that the numbers were true ... The reliable sources that Yemen
Times had were not only supporting the fact that the numbers were true, but they also
indicated that the actual number was more frightening than was initially thought (around
5,000,000 more than the given number).
"Feeling ashamed of themselves, and frightened of
getting into even more trouble, the government pulled out of its case, surrendering to
what is true and honest journalism. This is not a victory for Yemen Times alone. It is the
victory of the voice of the truth."
THE OFFENDING
FIGURES: Main sources of revenue to the state over the last 20 years (million US$)
Cumulative Revenue from Oil |
10,000 |
Saudi Arabia |
2,400 |
The World Bank |
1,160 |
Germany |
720 |
Japan |
586 |
The Netherlands |
541 |
UN Bodies (UNDP, WFP, etc.) |
453 |
Kuwait |
362 |
International Monetary Fund |
350 |
Abu Dhabi Development Fund |
297 |
The European Union |
256 |
Others |
5,375 |
TOTAL |
22,500 |
|
|
|
|
SOCIALIST
PARTY CONGRESS THE YEMEN Socialist Party
(YSP) held its first congress for 13 years on November 28-30, signalling what - its
leaders hope - will be the start of a revival in the party's fortunes.
The formerly-Marxist YSP came to power in southern Yemen
after the British withdrawal in 1967 and ruled the People's Democratic Republic until
unification with the north in 1990.
The last party congress in 1985 was marred by a serious
rift in the party which brought armed conflict in January 1986. Thousands were killed and
President Ali Nasser Mohammed was deposed and - along with many of his supporters - went
into exile.
After unification, the YSP government jointly with
President Salih's (northern) General People's Congress. Ali Salim al-Baid, the YSP's
secretary-general, became vice-president of the unified state.
In the first multi-party elections, in 1993, the YSP lost
ground, with its support mainly concentrated in the less-populous south. Fighting broke
out between northern and southern forces in 1994, and al-Baid proclaimed a separate state
in the south - though it was defeated within a few weeks.
The secession attempt caused further divisions in the YSP,
as did the party's decision to boycott the 1997 parliamentary elections.
One of the main goals of the November congress was
apparently to heal old wounds. Shortly before the gathering, ex-President Mohammed visited Aden, reportedly seeking confirmation from President
Salih that the general amnesty for socialists (excluding the leaders convicted after the
1994 secession attempt) was still valid.
According to reports, 1,351 delegates attended the
congress, among them 182 women. Representatives of several other parties, including the
ruling General People's Congress party and the main opposition party, Islah, attended the
opening session. Leaders of left-wing parties from other parts of the Arab world - Nayef
Hawatmeh of the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine and Yusef al-Faisal of
the Syrian Communist Party - also attended.
YSP delegates from Hadhramaut province boycotted the
congress in protest at the disappearance of Hassan Ba Awm, a member of political bureau,
following a demonstration earlier this year.
At the opening session, the YSP's secretary-general, Ali
Salih 'Ubad, criticised the government for not taking its calls for reconciliation at face
value. He condemned the policy of "exclusion" against the party since the 1994
war. "We are subjected to severe measures, the party is considered illegal, its funds
are still blocked and its party offices occupied
We call once again for an end to
the policy of exclusion and violence and for respect for the consitution," he said.
Mr 'Ubad called for the return of the exiled leadership,
some of whom have been condemned to death
in their absence. The final communique from the congress announced that the expulsion of
four former leaders from the party was being rescinded. The four are: Ali Salim al-Baid
(former secretary-general), Haidar Abu Bakr al-Attas (former prime minister), Salih 'Ubaid
Ahmad (politburo member) and Salim Salih Mohammed (former assistant secretary-general).
Mr 'Ubad said the party was also in favour of the return
of all members who had left it - a reference to ex-President Mohammed and Abd al-Qadr
Bagammal (currently Yemen's foreign minister and a member of the GPC).
In an interview with the Yemen Times (7.12.98), Mr 'Ubad
said: "We decided that we will let all bygones be bygones, whether it is with our own
members or with other members of our society. I challenge the others to start with a clean
slate in full co-operation to build Yemen of the 21st century."
But he complained that in holding its congress, his party
had been exposed to all kinds of intimidation and blackmail on the part of the
authorities. "The political leadership, governors, military and security officers and
other senior officals were involved in a sustained effort to tell us what we should
do."
President Salih, speaking at a ceremony to mark the 31st
anniversary of the British withdrawal from Aden on November 30, described the YSP as
"a secessionist party which refuses to modify its old methods." He called on the
party to apologise for the war of 1994.
Vice-President Abd al-Rabbu Mansur described the congress
as illegitimate on the grounds that the its delegates had not been properly elected
because the party structure had been destroyed in 1986.
Meanwhile the government newspaper, October 14, commented:
"The YSP is chewing over the past and continues to follow methods of deception, lies
and muzzling of mouths
The servants cannot live in a democracy, because they are
slaves to the complexes of the past."
The army newspaper, September 26, urged YSP members to
abandon Marxist ideology and establish internal party democracy.
|
|
"LIBYAN INCIDENT" ON PLANE ABOUT 150 Yemenis
aboard a chartered plane attempted - but failed - to break the UN embargo on flights to
Libya on December 9.
The aircraft, an MD-90, chartered from a private Egyptian
company, AMC, was carrying a "people's delegation to Libya", including
(according to the Yemen Times) members of parliament - some of them from the ruling GPC -
sheikhs, and other "Yemeni personalities".
Officials at Sana'a airport, from where the plane took
off, said it was originally heading for Cairo and that the passengers were intending to
travel from there by land to Sirte, in Libya, where the Libyan General People's Congress
was meeting. However, when the plane was in the air passengers demanded to fly directly to
Libya.
The pilot landed the plane at Djerba in southern Tunisia
(about four hours' drive from Tripoli) where the passengers initially refused to disembark
but later went to a waiting room. They then returned to the plane, which refuelled at
Cairo before returning to Sana'a.
Tunisian authorities said the passengers claimed the
destination in their chartering contract was Tripoli. The incident was therefore not a
hijacking, as early reports had suggested, but "a dispute between passengers who
hired the plane and the airline company."
|
|
GETTING TOUGH ON
KIDNAPPERS THE KIDNAPPING of four German
tourists looks set to provide the first real test of the government's new "get
tough" policy against tribesmen who take hostages - especially foreign hostages. On
December 16 troops were reportedly massing in the area where the Germans - who include
three women - were believed to be held, after a deadline passed without their release.
Norbert Degen, Petra Penglista, Rozwita Adlung and Inge
Brunner were kidnapped by the Bani Dhabyan tribe near the Yislah pass, 60 km south of
Sana'a, as they returned to the capital after a trip. Armed men stopped their car and
forced them into another vehicle which drove off to the remote mountain stronghold of Wadi
Zinah (120 km south-east of Sana'a) in Marib province. It was the fourth kidnapping by the
tribe in the space of 14 months (see Kidnap Chronicle).
On August 4, President Salih issued a decree introducing
the death penalty for kidnapping and several other offences after the problem began to
have a serious effect on tourism. Simultaneously a tribal conference condemned
hostage-taking and for a time it seemed that the incidents had stopped.
More recently, several Yemenis have been abducted and in
October two Belgians were held for a few hours by the Ba Kazim tribe - though officials
said they did not regard that as a "real kidnapping". The latest incident,
therefore, is the first test of the government's resolve to take a harder line where
tourists are involved.
The government hopes that the death penalty will deter
further kidnappings, but there is a danger that it may simply escalate conflict between
the state and tribes. Several members of the Bani Dhabyan have already been arrested (in
effect, taken hostage by the state) in order to put pressure on the kidnappers. If the
incident ends in executions or a shoot-out, it could assume the character of a blood feud,
rumbling on for years.
Dozens of foreigners have been kidnapped in Yemen over the
last few years, but all have been released unharmed. This has been due partly to tribal
attitudes regarding the treatment of "guests" and partly to the government's
willingness to see kidnappings resolved by negotiation. Although nothing is ever publicly
admitted, there is speculation that in the past kidnappers' demands (which usually include
better basic facilities in their villages) have sometimes been met. The problem with this
approach is that it resolves the immediate difficulty but encourages kidnapping in the
future.
In this case, the Bani Dhabyan have produced a long list
of demands, including schools and health centres, a link it to the water and electricity
grids, and also dams and roads. They are also said to want 200 government jobs for young
members of their tribe and scholarships to study at Sana'a University and at universities
abroad.
|
|
GERMAN
JOURNALIST ARRESTED SADIK HAMAIEL, a
writer/photographer for the Berliner Zeitung, was arrested on December 17 after
interviewing four German hostages and their
kidnappers from the Bani Dhabyan tribe.
Mr Hamaiel was returning to Sana'a from the hideout in
Marib province when he was stopped at a security check-point. As his car tried to get
away, there was an exchange of fire in which one of his escorts was wounded, according to
the Yemen Times (20.12.98). He was detained by the Interior Ministry.
On December 23 officials said he had been released after
agreeing "not to repeat what he had done." He left Yemen on December 27, without
his films and taped interviews - all of which were confiscated.
The case is reminiscent of an incident
in May when three members of a BBC television team were arrested after
interviewing Sheikh Mubarak Ali Saada after the Bani Dhabyan kidnapped a British family.
The journalists were later tried under the press law, but were acquitted.
A government-imposed deadline on December 16 passed
without the release of the hostages. Meanwhile the authorities have arrested numerous
members of the tribe and troops have reportedly shelled several villages.
Sheikh Ahmed Obad Shuraif, chief sheikh of the Bani
Dhabyan, recently called tribal leaders to his home to discuss the situation. "Many
of my tribesmen filled up my house in Sana'a as they flee government forces trying to
arrest them. The government has decided to arrest anybody who belongs to this tribe,"
he told the Yemen Times. |
|